A Must-Have Deal or a Risk: The Market Is Divided on Whether to Buy Anthropic Shares at the IPO

Market participants debated whether to buy Anthropic shares during the IPO—or to wait / Photo: Samuel Boivin / Shutterstock.com
Anthropic, the developer of the Claude chatbot, is going public this week. Taking into account the private placement of shares, the deal could become the largest in history. However, market participants are divided on whether to buy shares in the AI developer as part of the offering: some expect to profit from the rapid development of artificial intelligence, while others believe the company is overvalued and point to high infrastructure costs and legal risks. Business Insider surveyed five professional investors: two are ready to participate in the offering, two are opposed to buying, and one is open to making a small investment.
What People Are Saying in the Market
— Phil Blancato, chief market strategist at Osaic, said he would have bought Anthropic shares during the IPO. According to him, it’s a must-buy for anyone who believes that AI will change the way people live and work. According to estimates by the research firm IDC, cited by Anthropic, the economic impact of AI adoption could reach $22.5 trillion by 2031. “Even if Anthropic captures only a small share of that value, the company will still have the potential to grow much larger than it is today,” he said. Among the risks, the strategist highlights expenses for computing power and infrastructure, which grew faster than revenue in the last quarter. In addition, the company’s data center capacity must be reserved years in advance, whereas customers can reduce their usage much more quickly or switch to cheaper alternatives.
— Dhruv Manikta, Chief Investment Officer at True North Advisors and Western Alternative Strategies, is open to making a small investment in the AI developer during its IPO. His multi-family office, with $5.9 billion in assets, has already purchased shares in Anthropic on the private market “at a much lower price”. The company’s current valuation—at the upper end of the range , around $1.4 trillion, factoring in full dilution—is too high to recommend a buy to everyone: it assumes “unreasonably high” growth, the investor believes. According to Maniktala’s calculations, Anthropic would need $3.5 trillion in annual revenue to finance its planned expansion of data center capacity. This is equivalent to AI spending of $1,750 per month per worker in the U.S., including hairdressers and fast-food employees. At the same time, in his opinion, given the sheer scale of the possibilities, it is “impossible to predict” what will happen next, and those with spare cash should still set aside a small amount to invest in the company’s stock.
— Stephanie Link, chief investment strategist at Hightower Advisors, would also buy Anthropic stock, but only a small position, given the expected volatility. In her view, the AI giant’s valuation of $1.13–1.3 trillion is much more attractive than the previously discussed $2 trillion. On Tuesday evening, reports emerged that the company might go public at a price closer to a valuation of $1.5–1.6 trillion. Link also points out that demand for the shares is six times greater than supply, and highlights the company’s rapid business growth: Revenue for the first nine months of 2026 increased by 1,206% year-over-year, and in the third quarter, it rose by 47% compared to the previous quarter. She is slightly concerned that the company’s five largest clients account for 21% of its revenue, but she expects this share to decline in the coming years as the company attracts new customers.
— Christine Hall, founder and investment director of Nia Impact Capital, prefers not to participate in Anthropic’s IPO. Among the risks she cites are the company’s debt burden, long-term lease commitments, complicated relationships with partners who are also competitors, an unproven business model, and uncertainty surrounding future AI margins. “Given the business model itself and the growing number of competitors, I would wait until there is a clearer path to independence and profitability,” Hull said. In addition, she points to “negative externalities” that aren’t factored into the price, as well as mounting public discontent: potential intellectual property lawsuits, concerns about mass surveillance and privacy, and the environmental costs of data centers.
— Christian Jadolor, an investment analyst at Chicory Wealth, would not buy shares of the AI giant during the offering. He doubts the sustainability of Anthropic’s business model: computing costs are skyrocketing, and Americans are increasingly opposing the construction of data centers. Nearly 50% of the company’s revenue in the first half of the year came from cloud service providers, making it dependent on their demand and the pace of data center construction. In addition, Jadolor points to the risks of future regulation: Anthropic itself has warned that its models could pose an existential threat to humanity. “If AI gets out of control and this ‘existential’ threat materializes, Anthropic could face unprecedented legal risks,” the analyst believes.
Context
Anthropic has set its IPO price range at $70–78 per share. Trading in the AI company's shares is set to begin on November 19 on the Nasdaq under the ticker symbol ANT.
This article was AI-translated and verified by a human editor



