HomeNews
Share

Only two Mag7 stocks have outperformed the S&P 500 since the beginning of 2025. Should you buy them?

Investors have become more selective in choosing technology stocks

Venera Saifutdinova

Venera Saifutdinova

Oninvest reporter
Since the beginning of 2025, only two stocks from the Magnificent Seven have outperformed the S&P 500 / Photo: i viewfinder / Shutterstock

Since the beginning of 2025, only two stocks from the "Magnificent Seven" have outperformed the S&P 500 / Photo: i viewfinder / Shutterstock

Of the “Magnificent 7” — a group of major U.S. technology companies — only the shares of Google’s parent company, Alphabet, and Apple have outperformed the S&P 500 index since the beginning of 2025, according to MarketWatch. Charlie Bilello, chief market strategist at Creative Planning, pointed this out. Alphabet’s stock returned 50.8% to investors during this period, and Apple’s returned 42%, while the index itself returned 29%.

The other companies in the group—Amazon, Meta, Microsoft, Nvidia, and Tesla—underperformed the S&P 500 during the period in question.

Analysts attribute the success of Alphabet and Apple to how these companies have approached the implementation of artificial intelligence. However, the stock trajectories of the two companies have recently diverged: Apple shares are trading less than 2% below the closing high reached last week, while Alphabet shares have lost about 30% from their May peak.

In trading on November 18, Apple shares are up 0.5%, while Alphabet shares are up just over 1%.

What Analysts Are Saying

— “The market is currently ‘picking winners’ in the AI sector,” said Morningstar analyst William Kervin. Google has become a favorite among investors, in part thanks to its Tensor Processing Units (TPUs), which, in his assessment, rival Nvidia’s chips. In addition, he believes the company’s cutting-edge AI model, Gemini, is on par with developments from OpenAI and Anthropic.

Apple does not have its own AI models, but the company uses the technology as “a means to improve the user experience,” Kervin noted. It forms partnerships, spending significantly less on AI development than its competitors. Microsoft, Amazon, and Meta, on the other hand, are being “punished” by the market for their massive spending on AI infrastructure, the analyst added.

“Apple made the ‘wise decision not to play the same game as some of the other companies in the ‘Magnificent Seven,’” said Ben Carey, co-chief investment officer at Tandem Investment Advisors. He noted that other members of the group are spending “enormous” sums on AI competition, which could be considered a “less profitable” investment.

Cary also noted that since the beginning of 2025, investor sentiment regarding the prospects for Alphabet’s stock has shifted: the company has managed to establish itself as a major player in the AI sector, in part thanks to its TPU business, which, according to the analyst, “has likely taken a share of the market away from Nvidia and shaken its dominance” in the chip segment.

— Craig Moffett, an analyst at MoffettNathanson, sees Apple’s appeal precisely in its “lack of correlation” with the broader AI trend. When investors begin to doubt the ability of major players to recoup their infrastructure investments, they turn to Apple stock as a “safe alternative,” he noted. At the same time, Moffett believes that the iPhone 18 cycle “lags significantly” behind last year’s iPhone 17 cycle, and points to the risk that AI agents could “bypass Apple,” weakening the company’s control over its own ecosystem.

Overall, Wall Street views the outlook for both Apple and Alphabet stocks positively: the iPhone maker has 28 “buy” recommendations from analysts, 16 “hold” recommendations, and six “sell” recommendations. However, the consensus price target for Apple shares—$348.52 per share—is lower than the company’s current share price ($354.7). For Alphabet, the average target price—$392.36—exceeds the current share price by more than $100. Sixty-three analysts recommend buying shares of Google’s parent company, while eight recommend holding. There are no sell recommendations.

This article was AI-translated and verified by a human editor

Share

Trending

Stock Screener
Buy
Sell
‌
‌
‌
‌
‌
‌
‌
‌
‌
‌
‌
‌
‌
‌
‌
‌
‌
‌
‌
‌
‌
‌
Small Caps
Investment and Finance News