HomeNews
Share

Deutsche Bank shares fell 6%. The New York Times reported on the bank's dealings with Russian oligarchs

Internal Deutsche Bank documents leaked to journalists show that the bank ignored the risks involved in doing business with Russian billionaires for years

Photo: Poetra.RH / Shutterstock.com

Photo: Poetra.RH / Shutterstock.com

Deutsche Bank shares fell 6% at the start of trading in Germany on November 17 following the release of investigative reports titled “Inside Deutsche Bank” about the bank’s operations. Among other things, internal Deutsche Bank documents showed that the bank had ignored warnings from its own risk managers for many years and continued to serve major Russian businessmen, including billionaires Oleg Deripaska and Viktor Vekselberg, according to an investigation published by The New York Times.

Deutsche Bank did not wind down its operations in Russia until the spring of 2022, when other major Western lenders announced their withdrawal from the country. The investigation into the bank is based on a leak of more than 15 million internal documents—confidential reports, correspondence, and meeting minutes—which were analyzed by a consortium of more than 200 journalists.

What the Investigation Into Deutsche Bank's Operations in Russia Revealed

  • Two Camps—Risks vs. Profits

For years, two camps have been at odds at Deutsche Bank: The units responsible for combating financial crime insisted on cutting ties with oligarch clients and their companies, but the units responsible for generating revenue consistently prevailed in this dispute, according to a New York Times investigation.

For example, in 2014, Deutsche Bank’s internal committee on reputational risks ranked oligarch clients according to the level of risk they posed to the bank, with Oleg Deripaska coming in first, the newspaper reports. The bank’s financial crimes unit recommended severing ties with entities controlled by the billionaire. However, in other profit-oriented divisions, Deripaska was described as a “respected businessman”and a “long-standing client with a proven track record” who had a “significant portfolio of future deals”—and this argument prevailed, the NYT reports.

In 2015, according to the NYT, an internal Deutsche Bank presentation referred to Russian billionaires as the “foundation of sustainable growth” for the asset management division. The presentation noted that, at that time, only four countries had more households with net worth of at least $100 million than Russia, making it “an attractive market for asset managers.”

  • Focus on High-Net-Worth Clients

In 2017, Deutsche Bank paid hundreds of millions of dollars to settle allegations of “mirror trading”—a scheme through which, according to U.S. and U.K. regulators, up to $10 billion in Russian funds were laundered.

After that, Deutsche Bank scaled back some of its operations in Russia but did not shut down the business entirely; instead, it focused on its wealthiest clients—primarily oligarchs, according to the NYT. When the U.S. imposed sanctions against Russian businessmen in 2018, five Deutsche Bank clients—including Deripaska and Vekselberg—were on the list, the newspaper reports, citing the bank’s internal documents.

In 2019, one of Deutsche Bank’s consultants directly warned of the risks during a meeting of the supervisory board’s risk committee: if any of the Russian clients turned out to be “unscrupulous,” the bank’s potential losses would far exceed the revenue generated by that client.

At the time, Deutsche Bank remained under external supervision by the U.S. following the “mirror” transactions scandal. In 2020, lawyers from the external administration recommended that the bank “seriously consider” ceasing all “operations and services related to Russia,” the NYT reports, citing internal documents. According to the investigation, however, Deutsche Bank’s ties to wealthy Russians persisted.

A November 2020 internal review of the bank’s Russian strategy noted that 17 of the bank’s clients were included on the U.S. Treasury Department’s so-called “Kremlin List” of 210 officials and oligarchs. However, the same document emphasized “the importance and profitability of the Russian market.” In the spring of 2021, the bank’s board voted unanimously to cautiously expand its presence in Russia, citing improvements in its internal control system, the NYT reports.

  • Relocation to Luxembourg and Switzerland

According to the NYT, Deutsche Bank secretly transferred the accounts of oligarch clients to its offices in Luxembourg and Switzerland. Based on the NYT report, this began several years before the start of the war in Ukraine. Strict banking secrecy laws in Luxembourg and Switzerland could have provided a legal basis for refusing to disclose client data to authorities, although this was not cited as the reason for the transfers, the newspaper writes.

Deutsche Bank maintained that it was following standard industry practice by concentrating its asset management clients in these regions, rather than solely in Russia. The bank also emphasized that all of its Russian clients undergo appropriate due diligence.

Following the full-scale invasion of Ukraine in February 2022, the U.S. Department of Justice requested that the bank provide the names and account balances of Russian clients subject to sanctions. Since Deutsche Bank had transferred the oligarchs’ accounts to countries with strict banking secrecy laws, it had legal grounds to refuse to disclose details about these clients, the NYT reports. “Deutsche Bank is not authorized to disclose (banking secrecy) information regarding clients from Switzerland and Luxembourg to the U.S. Department of Justice,” a bank employee wrote in a letter.

Apparently, the bank also took advantage of a rule from the U.S. Department of the Treasury and did not disclose information about companies less than 50 percent owned by sanctioned oligarchs, including certain assets linked to Deripaska, according to the NYT.

  • Leaving Russia

As early as March 10, 2022—two weeks after the start of the full-scale war—Deutsche Bank CEO Christian Sewing wrote to employees that the bank would wind down only part of its Russian operations but would not withdraw from the market.

“We are often asked why we don’t withdraw from Russia entirely. The answer is that doing so would contradict our values. We have clients who cannot leave Russia overnight, and we will continue to support them as much as possible during this difficult time,” Seving explained in a letter quoted by the NYT.

However, on the same day, U.S. banking giants JPMorgan Chase and Goldman Sachs announced they were pulling out of Russia amid public pressure. The next day, March 11, 2022, Deutsche Bank reversed its decision and announced it was winding down its operations in the country, according to the NYT.

  • What did the bank say?

In a statement provided for the article, Deutsche Bank said it had acted lawfully and had never helped clients circumvent financial sanctions, promptly implementing all restrictions.

Vekselberg and Deripaska did not respond to the NYT’s request for comment, but they have called the sanctions against them unfair and have challenged them in court.

This article was AI-translated and verified by a human editor

Share

Trending

Stock Screener
Buy
Sell
‌
‌
‌
‌
‌
‌
‌
‌
‌
‌
‌
‌
‌
‌
‌
‌
‌
‌
‌
‌
‌
‌
Small Caps
Investment and Finance News