Shares of the protein shake manufacturer rose by a quarter. Should I buy?

Since the beginning of the year, BellRing Brands' stock has fallen 49% / Photo: Facebook / BellRing Brands
Shares of BellRing Brands, a manufacturer of high-protein food and beverage products, rose 24.07% during trading on November 18. The company beat revenue expectations, issued an optimistic outlook, and announced a three-year cost-cutting program. Management sees opportunities for growth in expanding sales of protein shakes at convenience stores and promoting new products, including a carbonated protein drink.
Details
Shares of BellRing Brands, a manufacturer of protein drinks and supplements, rose 24.07% to $13.66 on the New York Stock Exchange on November 18.
Investors reacted to the company’s report for the fourth quarter of fiscal year 2026: quarterly revenue increased by 6.8% to $692 million, compared with the $657.61 million analysts had expected. A 14.9% increase in sales offset lower prices and changes to the product mix. Sales were driven by ready-to-drink protein shakes, revenue from which rose by 7.1%. However, adjusted EBITDA (earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation, and amortization) fell by 43.4% to $66.4 million, partly due to $16 million in inventory-related expenses. Adjusted earnings per share fell from $0.51 to $0.22, compared with a forecast of $0.23.
For the full 2026 fiscal year, BellRing Brands’ revenue increased by 3.5% to $2.4 billion. However, net income fell by 31.8% to $147.4 million, and adjusted EBITDA declined by 40% to $288.8 million. The company cited rising raw material and transportation costs, import duties, and unfavorable price and product mix trends as contributing factors. At the same time, BellRing Brands announced a change in its chief financial officer and a three-year supply chain optimization program, which, according to CEO Michael Axelrod, is expected to yield at least $100 million in gross savings.
What's next?
For fiscal year 2027, BellRing Brands forecasts revenue of $2.32–2.42 billion—ranging from a decline of approximately 3% to growth of 1%. The company expects adjusted EBITDA of $310–350 million—a 7–21% increase over the previous year’s result.
BellRing Brands plans to promote new products and expand their distribution. The Ultimate Protein Shakes, containing 42 g of protein, have received positive initial feedback from consumers and retailers. Starting November 23, it will be available at participating 7-Eleven, Speedway, and Stripes stores across the United States. Another new product is the Sparkling Protein Soda. Management expects it to expand the occasions for purchasing protein drinks.
What Analysts Think
On November 18, Barclays maintained its “buy” rating and a price target of $12. On November 19, Bank of America Securities maintained its “sell” rating with a price target of $9. Following the rally on November 18, both price targets fell below the market price.
Since the beginning of the year, BellRing Brands shares have fallen 49%. Nine Wall Street analysts recommend buying the company’s stock, six recommend holding it, and one recommends selling it. The average target price is $13.38, which is below the closing price on November 18. The highest target of $20 implies a 46% increase in the stock price.



