Three investment gurus are steering clear of Anthropic. What’s giving them pause?

Ekman, Gandlach, and Burry shared their assessments of Anthropic's securities / Photo: Anthropic
Three financial gurus—Bill Eckman, CEO of Pershing Square Capital Management; “the bond king” Jeffrey Gundlach, and Michael Burry, who predicted the 2008 mortgage crisis—are in no hurry to buy shares of Anthropic, which debuts today, November 19, on the Nasdaq. Ekman called the company the most remarkable business story of this century, but declined to value it. Burry identified a “catastrophic vulnerability” in the IPO prospectus. And according to Gundlach, Anthropic does not deserve an investment rating.
"A Striking Story" That's Hard to Assess
“Anthropic is perhaps the most remarkable business story of this century, given the journey the company has taken from scratch to where it is today,” Pershing Square CEO Bill Eckman told Yahoo Finance. But the billionaire has no plans to buy shares in the AI giant immediately after its IPO. Ekman explained that he considers himself and his firm to be “very low-risk investors”—he is willing to invest in companies whose growth he can predict “with a very high degree of confidence.” “The company could be worth much more or much less, depending on several variables that are difficult to predict. That’s why it doesn’t fit into our portfolio,” he said.
Responding to a question about Anthropic’s negative free cash flow and losses in the billions, Ekman said the startup is close to—or has already achieved—“true operational profitability.” The net loss for the nine months ended September 30 was $104 billion. However, this was primarily due to paper losses from the revaluation of convertible bonds and derivative liabilities.
According to the financier, the main risk lies elsewhere: if Anthropic loses its leadership position, “real questions” will arise about its business model. Therefore, the startup cannot do without significant capital expenditures. It is possible to value the company using the discounted cash flow model, but this is “much more complicated” than, for example, for a hypothetical manufacturer whose sales are growing steadily by 5% per year. The range of scenarios for Anthropic is much broader, Ekman added.
Liabilities are 25 times greater than revenue
According to renowned short seller Michael Burry, whose story served as the basis for the film “The Big Short,” the closed-loop system of cross-financing that Anthropic detailed in its IPO prospectus makes it “catastrophically vulnerable to even the slightest slowdown in growth.”
"Anthropic is walking a fine line. I don't plan to buy Anthropic stock, and I don't expect to become a shareholder anytime soon," said the investor.
$895.4 billion—that is the amount of financial liabilities Anthropic disclosed prior to its IPO. However, according to Burry’s calculations, this is not the full picture: it does not include contracts with AMD or Google’s purchases of tensor processors for 2028–2031. Taking these contracts into account, liabilities reach $1.05–1.07 trillion. Furthermore, the short seller points out that it is unclear from the prospectus whether contracts with SpaceX totaling up to $120.5 billion are included in the disclosed amount. “Anthropic’s revenue over the past 12 months was $35.3 billion—25 times less than the company’s disclosed commitments,” Burry wrote. To cover its 2027 expenses, the AI company’s revenue would need to grow by 11.6% per month, he calculated. And these are far from the only risks the financier sees.
Does Anthropic Deserve an Investment Rating?
AI companies shouldn’t count on “the bond king” Jeffrey Gundlach buying their debt securities, which they will inevitably need to finance their future in the AI sector, according to Yahoo Finance. When asked if he would invest in Anthropic’s bonds, the investor—known for his blunt remarks—replied, “I wouldn’t touch them.”
“Anthropic is seeking an investment-grade rating. I think that if the company receives it, an investigation should be launched into the rating agency that assigns it, because Anthropic in no way deserves an investment-grade rating,” said Gandlach.
Context
Trading in Anthropic shares will begin during the session on November 19. The company priced the shares at $83, whereas the initially announced price range was $70–78. The startup and its founders sold 980 million shares, and the offering size was increased by nearly 20%.
Taking into account a $26 billion private placement, the AI developer has raised $107.3 billion, setting a new record. Anthropic’s valuation stands at $1.5 trillion.
On the day of the IPO, retail investors could buy Anthropic shares worth a net total of about $250 million, according to Vanda Research. That is more than twice the previous record set by SpaceX.
This article was AI-translated and verified by a human editor





