HomeNews
Share

SpaceX stock retreats despite Starship test success. What is Wall Street saying?

SpaceX fell 1.3% on Monday as the broader market slid, with tech stocks leading the selloff

Vladislav Osipov

Vladislav Osipov

SpaceX caught Starship for the first time after it returned to Earth / Photo: X / SpaceX

SpaceX caught Starship for the first time after it returned to Earth / Photo: X / SpaceX

Elon Musk’s SpaceX took a step toward making its Starship heavy-lift rocket reusable with its first successful catch of the spacecraft. Reuse would lower the cost of carrying cargo into orbit and could bring lunar missions closer. SpaceX shares fell more than 1% on Monday despite the milestone, though they held up better than the broader market. Several factors with little direct connection to space are weighing on the stock, Barron’s writes.

Details

SpaceX shares closed down 1.3% on Monday after briefly trading slightly higher. The stock held up better than the broader market. The S&P 500 lost nearly 2%, and the tech-heavy Nasdaq 100 dropped 2.7%.

It was the first trading session since SpaceX brought the upper stage of its super-heavy-lift Starship rocket back to Earth and caught it for the first time with the launch tower’s mechanical arms. It was a major engineering feat that could cut the time needed to get the vehicle ready to fly again. SpaceX still needs to show it can reuse the rocket quickly and economically, Seeking Alpha notes. The company also failed to recover its Super Heavy booster, which it had caught in earlier tests. This time, the booster exploded. SpaceX provisionally attributed the failure to a fuel shortfall, MarketWatch reports.

Photo: SpaceX

SpaceX has successfully caught Starship with its capture tower for the first time. What does this mean for the stock?

Starship is the largest rocket ever built, and its payload capacity could substantially reduce the cost of putting cargo into orbit. SpaceX plans to use those savings to expand satellite communications and develop AI technology in space. It also plans to use the rocket for missions to the Moon and Mars.

What analysts say

  • The “historic Starship catch moves SpaceX closer to full reuse,” Pivotal analyst Jeffrey Wlodarczak wrote, as quoted by Barron’s. He rates the shares “buy” and has a target price of $260 per share, 90% above Monday’s close.

  • “SpaceX’s Starship Flight 15 delivered what we believe is one of the most consequential technological achievements in modern aerospace history,” Raymond James analyst Brian Gesuale wrote in a note quoted by MarketWatch. He called the test flight and subsequent catch a “major de-risking event” for SpaceX shares. He sees the failed Super Heavy recovery as a problem the company can tackle.

The two Musk companies could announce a merger as early as December / Photo: Walter Cicchetti / Shutterstock.com

Bloomberg: SpaceX and Tesla could announce record merger in December

  • The successful flight was a reminder that rockets remain SpaceX’s core business, even as investors debate its expansion into telecommunications and its role as a supplier of computing power for AI, Evercore ISI analyst Kutgun Maral said.

  • Mizuho analyst Brett Linzey called the test results a “clear positive” for SpaceX shares.

  • “With Vulcan’s recent failed launch to reach orbit, we view SpaceX’s continued execution and deployment of its V3 satellites as incrementally positive,” RBC analyst Ken Herbert wrote in a note quoted by MarketWatch.

  • UBS analyst Gavin Parsons called Starship’s successful return “a major milestone on the path of achieving rapid reusability, lowering the cost of launch and enabling faster cheaper access to space,” Seeking Alpha reports. SpaceX remains a long way from the bank’s forecast of more than 1,500 launches in 2031, he said. He sees the next milestones as catching the booster, shortening the time between launches, operating from multiple launchpads, and flying the Ship 42 spacecraft again.

SpaceXs Default Risk Has Reached a Record High / Photo: Unsplash.com / Sven Piper

The cost of insurance against a SpaceX default has reached a record high. Is this a problem for investors?

  • “While one successful catch does not independently establish rapid reusability, it materially de-risks one of the most technically challenging components of SPCX’s long-term strategy,” KeyBanc Capital Markets analyst Michael Leshock wrote in a note quoted by Seeking Alpha.

  • “Overall stock implications: Very positive, although the market may not appreciate it on day one,” Morgan Stanley analyst Adam Jonas wrote in a note that appeared in the Seeking Alpha article

Drags on the stock

Democrats in Congress plan to launch investigations, including into restrictions on Starlink service in Ukraine, the Wall Street Journal reported on Friday. The restrictions in question affect Starlink terminals traveling faster than 160 kilometers per hour. Musk has said Starlink should be used only for defensive purposes, while claiming the U.S. government controls the use of Starshield, the military version of the service.

SpaceX did not respond to a request from Barron’s for comment on the planned Democratic investigations. The situation around Ukraine may be weighing on sentiment toward SpaceX, Barron’s writes.

AI stocks have also come under pressure after the surprise departure of Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang amid a spy scandal involving China. Huang left as investors were already questioning whether capital markets could finance the trillion-dollar AI buildout and weighing the implications of Democrats taking control of Congress. Democratic policies might slow AI development, Barron’s notes.

Share

Trending

Stock Screener
Buy
Sell
‌
‌
‌
‌
‌
‌
‌
‌
‌
‌
‌
‌
‌
‌
‌
‌
‌
‌
‌
‌
‌
‌
Small Caps
Investment and Finance News